three thick ribeye steaks

by

Those three thick ribeye steaks look absolutely incredible—beautifully seared with a deep mahogany crust, glistening juices, and that perfect medium-rare pink peeking through the edges. Resting on foil like that is classic post-sear technique to keep them warm and let the juices redistribute. Mouthwatering!

Here are five detailed ribeye steak recipes (plus bonus variations) inspired by your photo, focusing on methods that achieve that gorgeous sear and juicy interior. Each is explained step-by-step with tips, timings, and why it works. I’ve aimed for comprehensive guides so you can master them at home.

1. Classic Reverse-Sear Ribeye Steak (Best for Thick Cuts Like Yours – Edge-to-Edge Pink, Perfect Crust)

This is widely considered the gold standard for thick (1.5–2+ inch) ribeyes, as seen in sources like Serious Eats and Alton Brown. It cooks gently first for even doneness, then sears for crust without overcooking the exterior.

Ingredients (for 3 thick ribeye steaks, ~1.5–2 inches each):

  • 3 boneless or bone-in ribeye steaks (room temperature)
  • Kosher salt and freshly ground black pepper
  • High-smoke-point oil (e.g., avocado or canola)
  • Optional: 4 tbsp unsalted butter, 3 garlic cloves (smashed), fresh thyme/rosemary sprigs for basting

Steps:

  1. Dry Brine (Optional but Recommended): Up to 24 hours ahead (or at least 1 hour), generously salt both sides of the steaks (about 1 tsp kosher salt per pound). Place on a wire rack over a tray in the fridge uncovered. This seasons deeply and dries the surface for better searing.
  2. Preheat Oven: Set to 250–275°F (low and slow).
  3. Season and Prep: Pat steaks very dry. Season liberally with black pepper (and more salt if not brined).
  4. Slow Roast: Place steaks on a wire rack over a baking sheet. Insert a meat thermometer into the thickest part. Cook until internal temp reaches 115°F for medium-rare (about 20–40 minutes depending on thickness; yours look thick, so closer to 30–40 min). This gentle heat ensures no gray band—pure pink edge-to-edge.
  5. Rest Briefly: Remove and let rest 10 minutes (temp will rise a bit).
  6. Sear: Heat a heavy cast-iron skillet (or carbon steel) over high until smoking hot (open windows—smoke ahead!). Add 1–2 tbsp oil. Sear steaks 45–60 seconds per side for deep crust. Add butter, garlic, and herbs; tilt pan and baste foaming butter over steaks for 30–45 seconds. Sear edges/fat cap too.
  7. Final Rest: No long rest needed with reverse sear (juices are already set), but 5 minutes is fine. Internal temp should hit 130–135°F for medium-rare.
  8. Slice and Serve: Against the grain. Spoon pan juices over.

Why It Works: Low heat tenderizes via enzymes and dries the surface; high sear creates Maillard reaction flavor without overcooking.

Time: 45–90 minutes total. Doneness Guide: Rare: 120°F final; Medium: 140°F.

2. Traditional Pan-Seared Ribeye with Garlic Herb Butter Basting

Perfect stovetop method for that restaurant-style sizzle (inspired by Kitchn, Downshiftology, and Billy Parisi). Great if you want smoky kitchen drama.

Ingredients: Same as above, plus butter/herbs/garlic mandatory for basting.

Steps:

  1. Room Temp: Let steaks sit out 30–60 minutes. Pat ultra-dry.
  2. Season: Heavy kosher salt and pepper on all sides.
  3. Heat Pan: Cast-iron over medium-high until ripping hot (drop of water dances). Add 2 tbsp high-smoke oil.
  4. Sear First Side: Place steaks (don’t crowd—do batches if needed). Sear undisturbed 3–4 minutes for thick cuts until deep brown crust forms.
  5. Flip and Baste: Flip. Add 4 tbsp butter, smashed garlic, herb sprigs. Tilt pan; spoon foaming butter over steaks repeatedly for 2–4 minutes. Sear edges.
  6. Check Doneness: Use thermometer: Pull at 125°F for medium-rare (carryover to 130–135°F).
  7. Rest: 5–10 minutes tented with foil.

Tips: For thicker steaks like yours, finish in a 400°F oven 2–5 minutes after initial sear if needed. Ventilation essential!

Time: 15–25 minutes.

3. Alton Brown’s Perfect Pan-Seared (Stovetop-to-Oven Method)

A hybrid—quick sear then oven finish. Foolproof for consistent results.

Steps (Simplified):

  1. Preheat oven to 500°F. Heat dry cast-iron skillet on stove until smoking.
  2. Pat dry, season steaks heavily with salt (no pepper yet—it burns).
  3. Sear 30 seconds per side in dry pan.
  4. Transfer pan to oven: 2 minutes per side for medium-rare.
  5. Rest 5–10 minutes. Pepper now.

Why Great: Minimal flipping, even cooking.

4. Oven-Broiled Ribeye Steak

Hands-off, great for no-smoke kitchens.

Steps:

  1. Preheat broiler to high. Position rack 4–6 inches from element.
  2. Pat dry, season steaks.
  3. Place on broiler pan or wire rack over sheet.
  4. Broil 5–8 minutes per side (flip once) for medium-rare on thick cuts. Watch closely!
  5. Optional: Top with compound butter (softened butter mixed with herbs/garlic).
  6. Rest 10 minutes.

Tip: For extra flavor, sear stovetop 1 minute per side first.

5. Smoked then Reverse-Seared Ribeye (Outdoor Twist)

If you have a smoker/grill:

  1. Smoke at 225°F to 110–115°F internal (1–2 hours, wood like hickory).
  2. Rest, then sear hot (grill or cast-iron) 1–2 minutes per side.

Bonus Variations:

  • Herb Compound Butter: Mix softened butter with minced garlic, rosemary, thyme, parsley, lemon zest. Chill, slice atop hot steak.
  • Black Garlic Butter: For umami bomb—mash black garlic into butter.
  • Sides Ideas: Creamed spinach, roasted mushrooms, baked potatoes, asparagus.

Pro Tips Across All Recipes:

  • Thermometer is King: Instant-read is essential—don’t guess.
  • Resting: Critical for juiciness; juices redistribute.
  • Slicing: Always against the grain for tenderness.

Your steaks look like they nailed the reverse-sear or pan-sear perfectly—congrats! Try one of these next time; the reverse-sear might be your new favorite for those thick beauties. Enjoy! 🥩

Leave a Comment